[Ietf-not43] -02 requirements draft

[Rick Wesson]

Ted,


> discussion is a requirements discussion.  The requirement provides
> functionality: "Tell me all the domains administered by Example DNS
> /Tell me all the domains owned by Joe Example".  There are
> clear reasons to want this functionality.

no, I've asked for the requirement to be removed. only you and the draft
author have said no. There has been almost no discussion on this list on
or about the points in the requirements draft. I am stating that these
requirements are not fully baked and are not nearly cooked enough for
passing them off to the IESG.

none of the other requirements have conditions that require all members of
the mesh to participate in a query. this type of query does deserve
special attention because of the negative impact it could bring to those
who provide crip resolution service.

for these reasons I request that 3.2.3 be removed as a requirement,
otherwise please enumerate the clear reasons you have eluded to for
retaining this functionality.

-rick