[Ietf-not43] draft minutes

[Rick Wesson]

On Wed, 24 Jul 2002, Ted Hardie wrote:

> Hi,
> 	Below are draft minutes for the working group meeting in
> Yokohama; many thanks to Ed Lewis for taking these and sending them

> Charter discussion (WG chair Ted Hardie)
>      (see the WG charter page for content)
>      Scope has been reduced since the BoF held at Minneapolis
>      Now limited to domain registries with extensibility to others a plus
>
>      Question: "Why?"
>      RIR's and IRR's are removed to allow for a narrower scope, hence
>      higher probability of the WG accomplishing its goals
>


two points.. one of procedure, why are decisions being made at the meeting
and not on the list? If the RIRs and the IRRs want out of CRISP then the
name registries and registrars may want out too. To play fair the topic
needs to be discussed and consensus determined on the list.

secondly, without the RIRs and the IRRs the protocol does not improve ones
ability to navigate the heiracy of names and number delegations and as
such I believe CRISP should either solve the problem of all registries or
not exist.

I would like to understand how these decisions got made and why we all
were not consulted in the matter.

thanks,

-rick